New #1 Pizza Spot in Tuscaloosa? See the Rankings

It's been some time since we've updated the ranking of the best pizza in Tuscaloosa. Could there be any changes in the rankings?

Although there are many great pizza places in Tuscaloosa, we kept the list down to the top 5 places in the city. There are as few changes to this top five list from the list that was released before.

Is there a new #1 pizza in Tuscaloosa?

Here are the new updated top 5 pizza spots in Tuscaloosa according to ratings from Yelp.

#5- Mellow Mushroom

Canva

Located at 557 20th Ave Tuscaloosa, AL 35401 in Tuscaloosa, Mellow Mushroom is a new entry to the top 5 as of June 2025 on Yelp for top pizza spots with a 4.1 star rating.

#4- Roman Delight Pizza

Canva

Roman Delight Pizza came in at number three on Yelp for top pizza spots. With a huge 5-star rating, Roman Delight Pizza is easily one of the best in the city.

#3- TuscNY

Canva

Located at 229 McFarland Cir N in Tuscaloosa, TuscNY was rated the best pizza spot in Tuscaloosa with a 4.3 star rating. According to Yelp, the Mama Mia pizza is a popular selection.

#2- Decades Pub & Grub

Canva

Located at 2314 4th St Tuscaloosa, AL 35401 in Tuscaloosa, Decades came in at number two on Yelp for top pizza spots. With a 4.6 star rating, it looks like Decades is pumping out some great pizza in Tuscaloosa.